Community profile

Central Island Healthcare

825 Old Country Rd, Plainview, NY

Skilled Nursing

★ 2.623 reviewsRead reviews

About the community

About Central Island Healthcare

A source-provided community description has not been published yet. Verified care, address, pricing, and availability facts remain below.

Tracked public-data history

Recent changes

Each timeline item represents one source refresh. Times below show when our system detected a public-data change, not a notification from the community.

  1. October 24, 2026 at 6:49 AM PDT

    1 change detected in this data refresh

    Inspection record updated

    Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services cms quality profile is now available or has changed.

    Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ↗

Family and resident feedback

2.6 out of 5 from 23 reviews

Overall rating from Caring.com. Recent public reviews can help surface themes to ask about on a tour. Ratings belong to the original review source and are not independently verified by us.

★★★★★

Critical

I am a friend or relative of a current/past resident

The rooms are clean The care is inconsistent There are more invaluable employees than valuable when it pertains to caring, integrity and sense of urgency. Residents are left in the hallways and sometimes slumped over with the aids aware of their positioning in the wheelchairs. There is no concern for the dignity of the residents as they are often kept waiting for care when they are ringing the call bell. Often times residents are left screaming for help and when the staff is approached that a resident needs care, t…

LiLi68January 9, 2025Caring.com

★★★★★

Positive

I am a friend or relative of a current/past resident

My sister is in Central Island Healthcare. She's getting the care that she needs. She is on the floor where everybody is in a wheelchair, and mainly in bed. They have a big screen TV where they show some movies. I've seen nicer ones, but they didn't have rooms, and they would not take my sister. This one is working out OK. They change the bed every day. The nurses and the aides are nice. They have the laundry room. They do laundry every day and they bring it back on the hanger. This facility is good …

KrystynaJanuary 23, 2024Caring.com

★★★★★

Critical

I am/was a resident of this facility

The room is a solid 85 degrees. They can’t regulate it. Interaction with staff is pretty negligible. I asked for some water, they tell me I’m on fluid restriction. I’ve had 16 fluid oz of fluid all day. It is now 9.45 pm. At 8 pm, I was told no water until after 11. I told the nurse that because of the temp in this room, that I’ll dehydrated. I’m a dialysis patient and I need my medications. Been here since about 5:30, with no medication given. My BP is going up by the minute. This place shouldn’t be open to patien…

sorceressApril 5, 2023Caring.com

★★★★★

Positive

I am a friend or relative of a current/past resident

My Dad has been in this facility for long term care for several months now and we've been very happy with how well he has been cared for throughout each and every day. The nurses and aids have all been very kind and caring. They are attentive and on top of any concern we have. Very clean

Daughter71June 24, 2022Caring.com

★★★★★

Positive

I am a friend or relative of a current/past resident

My dad is at Central Island Healthcare and, thus far, they've been very, very helpful. His social workers are very engaged with us and letting us know his status. His RN case manager has been very helpful too with anything we need or any kind of services we need. Everybody's been very nice with the other assisted living facilities that they call and require information from. Central Island Healthcare also called me to make sure it was OK to speak to everybody, which was very nice of them. Because of COVID…

RyanApril 21, 2021Caring.com

★★★★★

Critical

I am a friend or relative of a current/past resident

Communication service terrible No one picking phones no one calling back when you leave massage. Rehabilitation service terrible , my father is there for rehabilitation after the 3 weeks of hospitalization he’s there 2 weeks already since then he was taken twice for rehabilitation instead of everyday like he should. In my opinion they are giving him some medication to make him loopy . He’s not the Same person I was transferring from hospital to rehab . They didn’t bring him for his Cardiologyst appt. because they d…

anetta KAugust 12, 2020Caring.com

Verified overview

What we know from public sources

Care options
Skilled Nursing
Operator
Not yet resolved
Public price status
Not publicly found
Last source check
October 24, 2026

Campus care settings

Skilled nursing

Central Island Healthcare

202 CMS-certified beds · CMS CCN 335284

Classification and identity evidence

Why this community appears in these categories

Skilled Nursing

Current CMS-certified nursing-home provider record; classification does not imply current admission availability.

Authoritative classification evidence · observed October 24, 2026

Skilled Nursing

Current CMS-certified nursing-home provider record; classification does not imply current admission availability.

Authoritative classification evidence · observed September 16, 2026

Facility-level payment evidence

Plans and public programs found in source records

These are directory, certification, contract, or participation records. They do not determine an individual’s eligibility, authorization, network benefits, cost sharing, admission, or whether a visit or stay is free.

Certified provider record

NY Medicaid

Payer: NY Medicaid · Service scope: Long Term Nursing

Room-and-board coverage is not publicly confirmed.

CMS Provider Data Catalog ↗ · source dated September 1, 2026

Certified provider record

Original Medicare

Payer: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services · Service scope: Short Term Skilled Nursing

Room-and-board coverage is not publicly confirmed.

CMS Provider Data Catalog ↗ · source dated September 1, 2026

Payment-program records

Medicare and Medicaid information

Medicaid

CMS provider type: Medicare and Medicaid

A contract or certification record does not guarantee coverage, eligibility, or current acceptance of new residents.

Medicare

CMS provider type: Medicare and Medicaid

A contract or certification record does not guarantee coverage, eligibility, or current acceptance of new residents.

Official oversight

Inspection and quality records

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services4/5 overall CMS rating · 3/5 health inspection · 3/5 staffing · 7 recent-cycle deficienciesView the official record ↗

Coverage last checked October 24, 2026 via Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.

Questions to confirm with the community

Additional care fees
Not publicly disclosed
Move-in fee
Not publicly disclosed
Exact unit availability
Confirmation required
Central Island Healthcare – Plainview, NY | CareOpenly