Community profile

Mary Agnes Manor

307 Porter Avenue, Buffalo, NY

Assisted LivingIndependent LivingMemory Care

★ 2.29 reviewsRead reviews

About the community

About Mary Agnes Manor

Mary Agnes Manor Retirement in Buffalo, NY is one of senior living communities in the area. To find the right community for your needs and budget, connect with one of A Place For Mom’s local senior living advisors for free, expert advice.

Family and resident feedback

2.2 out of 5 from 9 reviews

Overall rating from Caring.com. Recent public reviews can help surface themes to ask about on a tour. Ratings belong to the original review source and are not independently verified by us.

★★★★★

Positive

I am a friend or relative of a current/past resident

Mary Agnes Manor was excellent and they have very, very good people. They treat us like family, they make us feel welcome and comfortable, and we like that. When we dropped my grandmother off, it was a good feeling. They make you feel like family. The rooms have a beautiful view, and they're relaxing and safe. From my point of view, they're very good. Everybody says the staff treats you like family and they're pretty good. They have movies once in a while, they play bingo, they exercise, and they do …

★★★★★

Positive

I am a friend or relative of a current/past resident

My mother loved her time there! Her room was great, her floor was nice, quiet, clean and she got the exact level of care that she needed for that time! I'm very pleased with the facility and would recommend to any of my loved ones!

★★★★★

Critical

I am a friend or relative of a current/past resident

My Aunt is a resident of Mary Anges Manor. She went there to begin with because my grandmother was getting too old to take care of her and My Aunt fell at home and broke her back. She went to rehab and then was was placed at Mary Anges. The administration there were fully aware that my Aunt is mentally handicapped and also prone to falling. She hasn't even been there a year yet and she's already fallen 6 times. SIX TIMES. This last time she hit her head so hard that she got a brain hemorrhage. If this isn…

★★★★★

Critical

I visited this facility

We visited Mary Agnes Manor, which has an older and more outdated building. The view that they had was beautiful, and the outside looked nice. Inside, it just felt sterile, and was more like living in a hospital than a home. It didn't feel welcoming. They're willing to work with you in terms of the price, but only because they need to get more business. It wasn't right.

★★★★★

Critical

I am a friend or relative of a current/past resident

Do not put your relatives in this facility if you care anything bout their wellbeing. It is the single most disgusting facility I have ever been to.

★★★★★

Critical

I would not recommend this community!

The food at this community was terrible. Some of the staff were helpful, however most did not seem to want to take the time to help. I had to share a bedroom and bathroom with three other people.

Verified ReviewResident/clientIndependent Living

See category ratings

Cleanliness: 2.0 / 5
Friendliness: 2.0 / 5
Value for Cost: 2.0 / 5
Care Services: 2.0 / 5
Activities: 2.0 / 5

Verified overview

What we know from public sources

Care options: Assisted Living, Memory Care, Independent Living
Operator: Not yet resolved
Public price status: Not publicly found
Last source check: October 21, 2026

Official oversight

Inspection and quality records

Inspection coverage has not yet been completed for this community. “Not covered” is not the same as “no violations found.”

Coverage last checked October 21, 2026.

Questions to confirm with the community

Additional care fees: Not publicly disclosed
Move-in fee: Not publicly disclosed
Exact unit availability: Confirmation required

Mary Agnes Manor

About Mary Agnes Manor

2.2 out of 5 from 9 reviews

I am a friend or relative of a current/past resident

I am a friend or relative of a current/past resident

I am a friend or relative of a current/past resident

I visited this facility

I am a friend or relative of a current/past resident

I would not recommend this community!

What we know from public sources

Inspection and quality records

Questions to confirm with the community

Other communities near Buffalo

Bristol Home

Canterbury Woods Gates Circle

Peregrine Senior Living at Cheektowaga

Elderwood Assisted Living at Cheektowaga

Glenwell, a DePaul Senior Living Community

Juniper Glen Memory Care Assisted Living

Nearby starting prices

Senior living around Buffalo

Continue your search