Community profile

Aria at Mitchell Manor

5301 W Lincoln Ave, West Allis, WI

Skilled Nursing

20 published reviews availableRead reviews

About the community

About Aria at Mitchell Manor

A source-provided community description has not been published yet. Verified care, address, pricing, and availability facts remain below.

Family and resident feedback

20 published reviews available

Recent public reviews can help surface themes to ask about on a tour. Ratings belong to the original review source and are not independently verified by us. An overall rating is not available.

★★★★★

Critical

Poor attention to residents

Our sister has lived here for several years. Since the facility was sold to Aria, care has deteriorated badly. There have been frequent days no staff came to help her out of bed and to get dressed. She doesn't always get a shower every week. No one responded to her repeated pendant alarm 'calls' when she fell and couldn't get up; another resident heard her cries for help and personally went to find staff. The residents are currently confined to their rooms, and the rumor is that it's because of a bed bug infestatio…

See category ratings
Cleanliness
2.0 / 5
Friendliness
1.0 / 5
Value for Cost
1.0 / 5
Care Services
1.0 / 5
Activities
3.0 / 5
Staff
1.0 / 5
Meals & Dining
2.0 / 5
MegAugust 15, 2024Published source

★★★★★

Critical

This was a big disappointment. The community smelled. The residents didn't always have their own bathrooms and would have to use a shared bathroom in the hallway.

AnonymousSeptember 30, 2022Published source

★★★★★

Positive

I was not impressed with the size of the rooms, they were small. Also when walking in the carpets are worn and you can just tell that it needs some updating.

anonymousDecember 2, 2021Published source

★★★★★

Critical

Our loved one is in the early stages of dementia and doesn't need full-on memory care. But Aria at Mitchell Manor doesn't offer assisted living in that instance. They offered us memory care only.

anonymousNovember 22, 2021Published source

★★★★★

Critical

I would recommend it to other people

We are not sure at the moment what activities they are offering, but the value for cost is absolutely 5 stars. An area they could improve one would be their communication, that is about the biggest complaint we have with Aria at Mitchell Manor.

See category ratings
Cleanliness
4.0 / 5
Friendliness
5.0 / 5
Care Services
4.0 / 5
Staff
5.0 / 5
Meals & Dining
3.0 / 5
anonymousAugust 16, 2021Published source

★★★★★

Critical

Started good, ended terribly - happy we moved mom out

I am so glad we recently moved my mom out of Meadowmere/Aria. While we acknowledge the serious challenges COVID-19 placed on all of us, this facility basically just warehoused our mom for the last year, delivering cold meals to her apartment and offering little to no interaction. What hurt the most was the overall neglect and lack of empathy from key staff members, in particular the nursing staff. The facility was much nicer to us - and most importantly our mom - when we were paying full freight. After we spent dow…

See category ratings
Cleanliness
2.0 / 5
Friendliness
2.0 / 5
Value for Cost
1.0 / 5
Care Services
1.0 / 5
Activities
1.0 / 5
Staff
2.0 / 5
Meals & Dining
1.0 / 5
Jim PickettMarch 31, 2021Published source

Verified overview

What we know from public sources

Care options
Skilled Nursing
Operator
Not yet resolved
Public price status
Not publicly found
Last source check
October 21, 2026

Campus care settings

Skilled nursing

Aria at Mitchell Manor

50 CMS-certified beds · CMS CCN 525600

Classification and identity evidence

Why this community appears in these categories

Skilled Nursing

Current CMS-certified nursing-home provider record; classification does not imply current admission availability.

Authoritative classification evidence · observed September 16, 2026

Facility-level payment evidence

Plans and public programs found in source records

These are directory, certification, contract, or participation records. They do not determine an individual’s eligibility, authorization, network benefits, cost sharing, admission, or whether a visit or stay is free.

Certified provider record

Original Medicare

Payer: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services · Service scope: Short Term Skilled Nursing

Room-and-board coverage is not publicly confirmed.

CMS Provider Data Catalog ↗ · source dated August 1, 2026

Certified provider record

WI Medicaid

Payer: WI Medicaid · Service scope: Long Term Nursing

Room-and-board coverage is not publicly confirmed.

CMS Provider Data Catalog ↗ · source dated August 1, 2026

Payment-program records

Medicare and Medicaid information

Medicaid

CMS provider type: Medicare and Medicaid

A contract or certification record does not guarantee coverage, eligibility, or current acceptance of new residents.

Medicare

CMS provider type: Medicare and Medicaid

A contract or certification record does not guarantee coverage, eligibility, or current acceptance of new residents.

Official oversight

Inspection and quality records

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services3/5 overall CMS rating · 3/5 health inspection · 3/5 staffing · 7 recent-cycle deficienciesView the official record ↗

Coverage last checked October 21, 2026 via Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.

Questions to confirm with the community

Additional care fees
Not publicly disclosed
Move-in fee
Not publicly disclosed
Exact unit availability
Confirmation required
Aria at Mitchell Manor – West Allis, WI | CareOpenly