Community profile

The Eliot at Erie Station

12 John Street, Middletown, NY

Assisted LivingIndependent Living

★ 5.04 reviewsRead reviews

About the community

About The Eliot at Erie Station

Eliot at Erie Station in Middletown, NY is one of senior living communities in the area. To find the right community for your needs and budget, connect with one of A Place For Mom’s local senior living advisors for free, expert advice.

Family and resident feedback

5.0 out of 5 from 4 reviews

Overall rating from Caring.com. Recent public reviews can help surface themes to ask about on a tour. Ratings belong to the original review source and are not independently verified by us.

★★★★★

Positive

I am a friend or relative of a current/past resident

Staff was very helpful and polite. My family member always has good things to say and I am at peace knowing they are in great hands ❤️

tdouble126May 29, 2019Caring.com

★★★★★

Critical

There were 3 or more people outside smoking. I said I had an appointment and was told I didn't have one. I had the time wrong for my appointment and I left and did not go back for the tour. I didn't like the look or feel of the place.

See category ratings
Cleanliness
1.0 / 5
Friendliness
1.0 / 5
Value for Cost
1.0 / 5
AnonymousJanuary 25, 2019Published source

★★★★★

Positive

I am/was a resident of this facility

The Eliot at Erie Station houses only approximately 100 residents. They offer three meals a day, laundry washed and folded, room cleaned, and bed made every day. They have a chain of command for any complaints. The staff is really good, and I get my meds every day. They'd send somebody upstairs to get my meds to me if they forgot them. They're very good at what they do. They have a DJ, celebrate birthdays, and go to the Wal-Mart or the Rosemont. One of their cooks used to own a restaurant in Middletown, s…

Ed ZMarch 28, 2018Caring.com

★★★★★

Positive

I visited this facility

When I walked in to The Eliot I immediately noticed the staff were smiling, residents looked happy and were having a great time at activities, everyone said hello as I walked by! David was able to answer all my questions and Nicole ran the office like a true professional. When my Dad is finally ready to make a decision, The Eliot is definitely on top of the list.

Dan CMarch 22, 2018Caring.com

★★★★★

Positive

I visited this facility

We have met with Eli at the home and we are so impressed with the knowledge, information, and comfort he has provided. If you need someone who is on the ball, can get things done, and be mindful of your family concerns look no further.

G.O.B.November 15, 2017Caring.com

★★★★★

Positive

We have met with [Removed] at the home and we are so impressed with the knowledge, information, and comfort he has provided. If you need someone who is on the ball, can get things done, and be mindful of your family concerns look no further.

See category ratings
Cleanliness
5.0 / 5
Friendliness
5.0 / 5
Value for Cost
5.0 / 5
George O'brianNovember 15, 2017Published source

Verified overview

What we know from public sources

Care options
Assisted Living, Independent Living
Operator
Not yet resolved
Public price status
Not publicly found
Last source check
October 21, 2026

Source-published features

Amenities and services

Grouped so you can scan what affects day-to-day life before opening an operator page.

Meals & dining

  • Meals Provided

Health & wellness

  • Staffing & Ancillary Services
  • Incontinence Care
  • Memory Care
  • Diabetic Care
  • Medication Management
  • Non-Ambulatory Care

Activities & engagement

  • Devotional Activities Offsite
  • Activities On-site

Outdoor spaces

  • Indoor Common Areas

Official oversight

Inspection and quality records

Inspection coverage has not yet been completed for this community. “Not covered” is not the same as “no violations found.”

Coverage last checked October 21, 2026.

Questions to confirm with the community

Additional care fees
Not publicly disclosed
Move-in fee
Not publicly disclosed
Exact unit availability
Confirmation required